Skip to main content

๐ŸฅŠ What Fight Club Taught Me About AI Policy in the Classroom

๐Ÿง ๐Ÿ’ฅ What does Fight Club have to do with AI policy in education? More than you’d think.

Let’s talk about something no one seems to want to talk about: AI in student work.

๐Ÿงฉ Thought Experiment: Why Is AI Use Considered Cheating?



๐ŸŽ“๐Ÿ“ฑ Imagine this scenario: You receive an essay that’s technically perfect, but something feels… off. You suspect AI helped write it. But before jumping to conclusions, consider:
Why would students turn to AI in the first place?

Two possibilities came to mind:
๐Ÿ•’ They believe the assignment is a waste of their time.
❓ They don’t understand why they’re doing the task.

And then I had to ask myself the tough question:
๐Ÿชž What am I not doing that has led them to these assumptions?

๐Ÿ‘Š Back to Basics: My “No-AI” AI Policy
Here’s the twist—just like in Fight Club, I don’t start by talking about AI at all. I start with connection.

๐Ÿ’ฌ Step 1: The One-on-One Meeting



At the start of each term, I require a 1:1 student conference. This 5–10 minute chat sets the tone:
  • ๐Ÿ‘‚ I get to know them—what they care about, what they’re juggling.
  • ๐Ÿ“š I explain my expectations, including how we’ll handle questionable submissions.
  • ๐Ÿค I stress that I care more about their learning than perfect products.

๐ŸŽ™️ Step 2: Normalize the Conversation


When a submission feels AI-generated, I don’t accuse. I simply say:

  • “Let’s grade this together.”

We meet. I ask questions. We talk about the assignment. I assess their understanding orally. Only after that do I bring up the AI question—non-accusatorially.

๐Ÿง  Step 3: Shift from Policing to Coaching



Once fear of punishment is removed, students are surprisingly honest. They talk about their process. We discuss tools, drafts, what they might do differently next time. I often end the meeting saying:

  • “Thanks for being open. We both learned something today.”

๐ŸŽฏ Key Takeaways

  • You don't need a surveillance state to address AI. You need trust.
  • Students cheat when the why is missing or the workload feels meaningless.
  • Conversations—not accusations—build a culture of integrity.

๐Ÿ› ️ Ideas You Can Try Tomorrow

  • Schedule short 1:1s during the first two weeks of class.
  • Add a “grade together” policy to your syllabus.
  • Allow space in assignments for voice, flexibility, and revision.
  • Frame AI conversations around learning, not discipline.

๐Ÿงจ Final Thought: The Second Rule of Fight Club


“The second rule of Fight Club is: You DO NOT talk about Fight Club.”

We can’t afford to follow that rule.

Talk to your students about AI—even if it’s indirectly. Build policies around human connection, not suspicion.

That’s how we fight the real fight.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Using AI to Build Support Tools for Students: Pacing Guide Generators and Beyond

In virtual and asynchronous education, one of the most persistent challenges is keeping students on track without daily in-person check-ins. When learners fall behind, they can quickly become overwhelmed, especially when teacher oversight is limited. Enter AI-powered support tools. ๐Ÿง  Why AI in Pacing Matters As educators and instructional leaders, we can now customize AI tools to meet our students’ real needs. One simple yet powerful example? ✅ The AI-Powered Pacing Guide Generator This tool creates individualized learning schedules based on each student’s: ✅ Start date ✅ Course length ✅ Available work days ๐Ÿ› ️ What Is a Pacing Guide Generator? A pacing guide generator takes a few simple inputs (course content, end date, skipped days) and automatically produces a custom, student-friendly plan . With just a few lines of code, you can generate pacing guides directly into Google Docs or Google Sheets with minimal effort. ๐ŸŽฏ Use it once, reuse it forever. ๐Ÿ’ก Why This Chan...

ChatGPT & Academic Integrity

  The edu-sphere is abuzz with the potential of ChatGPT , both for good and for evil. How should teachers and schools react?  If in the madness of teaching during the holiday season, you missed the coverage of the new chatbot that writes a variety of genres, including essays, lesson plans, and even computer code, you can read more here  and here .  I concur with Matt Miller and others that blocking access to one chatbot is an exercise in futility. For one, filters likely only work on campus networks. Moreover, more chatbot tools will likely emerge as the technology grows in popularity. It would be a waste of manpower to try to keep up with all of them.  What can teachers do, then, but embrace the potential? Embrace, also, the responsibility to incorporate education and model best practices. For instance, MLA and other style guides provide guidelines for citing the outputs of chatbots and other AI tools. Did you use ChatGPT to generate that stellar parent-teache...

AI Tools & Toys to Try

In today's world, Artificial Intelligence has become an integral part of our daily lives.  From education to productivity, audio to video, art to fun tools and toys, AI is making a significant impact in each and every aspect. With AI tools, we can simplify and automate many tasks, make our lives easier, and have some fun while we're at it. In this post, we'll dive into the world of AI and explore some of the most interesting and innovative tools available. So buckle up, grab a cup of coffee, and let's explore the fascinating world of AI tools together! (Intro draft generated with ChatGPT ). The list of possible AI tools quickly becomes overwhelming. Furthermore, tools range from free, to freemium, to paid accounts. I have included a list of some great tools for beginners, with not to various applications for AI for teachers. I have tried out each tool and, where possible, including a sample of what I created in a relatively short amount of time. Each tool included is av...